One Call, That’s All 800-404-9000
CASE EVALUATIONS ARE FAST, EASY, AND FREE.
When personal injury case settlement talks break down, the case moves into a formal legal process where evidence, witness testimony, and legal arguments are presented before a judge or jury to determine fault and compensation. For people facing serious injuries, long recovery periods, or disputed liability, the trial process can feel uncertain without guidance from Utah injury lawyers. At Craig Swapp & Associates, we represent injury victims throughout Utah and are focused on building strong cases that are ready for negotiation or trial when necessary.
Most personal injury claims settle before trial. Insurance companies often prefer to avoid the cost, risk, and unpredictability of courtroom litigation. However, there are situations where settlement negotiations stall, making trial the next step.
A personal injury case may go to trial because:
Serious truck accidents, traumatic brain injuries, spinal cord injuries, and wrongful death claims are more likely to involve litigation because the financial stakes are higher.
In Utah, personal injury lawsuits are generally subject to a four-year statute of limitations from the date of the accident, though wrongful death and medical malpractice claims often involve shorter deadlines. Missing those deadlines can prevent an injured person from recovering compensation altogether.
Before a trial can occur, the injured person’s attorney files a formal complaint in civil court.
This document outlines:
Once the lawsuit is filed, the court establishes deadlines and schedules that both sides must follow. Although the trial may still be many months away, the case officially enters litigation at this stage. For many injured individuals, this is the point where having a personal lawyer in Utah becomes particularly important because procedural rules, deadlines, and evidentiary requirements become more demanding.
One of the most important stages in the trial process is discovery. Discovery is the formal exchange of information between both sides. During discovery, attorneys gather evidence such as medical records, accident reports, expert evaluations, and witness statements.
The parties may also conduct depositions. A deposition is sworn testimony taken outside of court where attorneys question witnesses, doctors, accident reconstruction professionals, or the injured person directly.
Discovery can last several months or even longer in catastrophic injury cases. Courts allow this phase because both sides have the right to examine the evidence before the trial begins.
Insurance companies frequently use discovery to challenge the extent of injuries or argue that a victim had pre-existing conditions. Strong documentation and medical evidence often become central to proving damages.
Many Utah injury trials involve expert testimony. Experts help explain technical issues that jurors may not understand without professional guidance.
Common expert witnesses in injury litigation include:
For example, if a person suffers a permanent spinal injury, an economist may calculate future lost earning capacity and long-term care costs. A physician may testify regarding surgeries, rehabilitation needs, chronic pain, or permanent limitations. Expert testimony can strongly influence how juries understand both liability and damages.
Even after a personal injury lawsuit is filed, settlement negotiations usually continue. In fact, many cases resolve shortly before trial.
Courts may require mediation, where both sides meet with a neutral third party to attempt settlement discussions. Mediation allows the parties to negotiate privately while avoiding the uncertainty of a jury verdict.
Sometimes, insurers become more willing to settle after reviewing deposition testimony, expert reports, or newly uncovered evidence. Trial preparation itself often increases pressure on both sides to compromise. Still, if no agreement is reached, the case proceeds to court.
When people ask what happens if an injury case goes to trial, they are usually referring to the courtroom phase itself. While every case differs, most personal injury trials follow a structured process.
If the case is heard by a jury, attorneys participate in jury selection, also called voir dire. During this process, potential jurors are questioned to identify possible bias or conflicts. Both sides aim to select jurors who can fairly evaluate the evidence.
Each attorney gives an opening statement outlining their position. The plaintiff’s attorney explains how the accident occurred, why the defendant is responsible, and the damages being sought. The defense then presents its own version of events.
This phase often takes the longest. Witnesses testify under oath, and attorneys present evidence to support their arguments.
The injured person may testify regarding:
Doctors, experts, eyewitnesses, and investigators may also testify. The defense has the opportunity to cross-examine witnesses and challenge evidence presented by the plaintiff.
Once all evidence is presented, personal injury lawyers summarize their arguments during closing statements. They explain why the jury should rule in their client’s favor.
After receiving legal instructions from the judge, the jury deliberates privately. Jurors decide whether the defendant is liable and, if so, how much compensation should be awarded. The verdict becomes legally binding unless successfully challenged on appeal.
There is no single timeline for a personal injury trial in Utah.
Some cases resolve within months, while others may take years, depending on:
Because litigation can become lengthy, injured individuals should continue medical treatment and maintain documentation throughout the process.
Understanding what happens if an injury case goes to trial can help injured individuals consider pursuing a settlement or preparing for the trial process ahead. Our personal injury lawyers at Craig Swapp & Associates are dedicated to managing your case through whichever path serves your interests best, whether that involves a settlement or a trial. Call us today at 866-357-2526 or contact us using our online form to schedule your free initial consultation.
Written By: Ryan Swapp Legal Review By: Craig Swapp