Once the dust and your nerves settle after a car accident, the first questions you are likely to ask yourself are “What happened?” and “Who’s fault is it?”

Who caused the accident or who is at fault is dependent on your state’s definition of negligence. Comparative, modified comparative, and contributory are the three types of negligence Insurance companies use to determine who is at fault in a car accident.

Comparative Negligence

Comparative Negligence is defined as your percentage of fault compared to the other party involved. This means you can still seek damages in proportion to your degree of responsibility for the accident even if you’re only partially at fault. For example, if the other driver involved is determined to be only 60% at fault, then you can seek up to 60% of the settlement from the other driver’s insurance. Negligence laws differ in each state, so be sure and check with your local police department and insurance company.

Modified Comparative Negligence

Some states use modified comparative negligence to determine fault. Illinois for example, only

allows you to seek damages from the other party’s insurance if you are found to be less than 50% at fault.

Contributory Negligence

Contributory Negligence is black and white when determining fault. To seek damages, you must be 0% at fault in an accident. A good example of this type of negligence is if your car is struck while legally parked on the street. The other driver would be 100% at fault and in that instance you could seek compensation for car repair expenses.

So what can you do to help determine fault in a car accident?

Get A Police Report:

A police officer’s objective and more reliable report can help insurance companies more accurately determine who is at fault in a car accident.

Gather Evidence:

Take photos of the accident and get information from eyewitness drivers and provide it to your insurance company. Gathering evidence can help support your case if you believe the other driver is at fault.

Avoid Admitting Fault:

State only the facts of the car accident as it happened to you. Always cooperate with police and exchange information with the other drivers involved, but avoid admitting fault. Ultimately, the car accident could be a result of factors unknown to you, so allow fault to be determined objectively by the police and your insurance company.

Sometimes determining negligence or fault can be tricky. Remember that the legal definition of negligence can vary from state to state, so always check with local authorities and your insurance company if you have any questions. If you live in Utah and need legal help reach out to Craig Swapp & Associates for a free initial consultation.

Written By: Ryan Swapp Legal Review By: Craig Swapp

Schedule a Free Consultation

or call: 800-404-9000

Client Reviews

“I was concerned with all the paperwork”

Before calling your firm I had 2 big worries. One was I didn’t want to do more paper work, and that fear was resolved when I had to do very little, but Craig Swapp and Assoc. did most of it, and when I did have to come in to sign papers they worked around the times I could do it. Worry 2 was I didn’t want people to think I was “sue happy” and that I was just out to get money. I just wanted my bills to be paid for that were from the accident, and that was resolved I think by Mr. Wes Mortenson and Theresa because they listened to what I had to say.

Amber W.,

Spokane, WA

"I would hire them in a second"

My biggest fear was not having all the expenses caused by the accident paid for in full. I was assured they would be taken care of but I admit I was skeptical. When we wrapped everything up (which happened quicker than I was originally told) I had extra money in my pocket. I honestly thought there was a catch but my attorney explained everything to me in detail. If I am ever in that position again I’ll be giving Craig Swapp a call.

Robert N.,

Spokane, WA

"I was afraid of the fees"

I was afraid of the fees I would have to pay a lawyer. I waited over a year before hiring your law firm. I finally reached out to your online help where they were able to help me understand the process and what would happen. In all honesty I absolutely loved working with the individuals that were involved in my case. They were genuine & heartfelt about my case. It felt as though they really cared and were concerned about me, not just as a client but as a person.

Lacey B.,

Salt Lake City, UT

"I was afraid that my issue was too small"

I was afraid that my issue was too small to be handled, and that it would just be rejected. Or that I’d end up having to pay for my medical expenses and any of your teams expenses. I would definitely answer yes, it was resolved! I wasn’t ever made out to feel like my little issue didn’t matter, and my expenses were paid for- just what I wanted/needed.

J. Rohas,

Caldwell, ID

"I am very pleased with the results"

My biggest fear was that it would be pointless to pursue legal action in my case. I felt like maybe I didn’t have much of a case. After speaking with Paul, I realize it was not of my own fault and that others can be held responsible for the pain and suffering I went through.

Dollie J.,

West Jordan, UT

READ ALL TESTIMONIALS