One Call, That’s All 800-404-9000
CASE EVALUATIONS ARE FAST, EASY, AND FREE.
Defense medical examinations (DME) play a major role in many personal injury claims because the findings often influence settlement negotiations, insurance decisions, and courtroom evidence. Understanding how medical exams work helps injured people protect their rights and avoid mistakes that could affect the value of their claims.
For injury victims throughout Utah, Idaho, Washington, Montana, Oregon, Wyoming, Colorado, and Arizona, having a personal injury attorney during every stage of an injury case is important. At Craig Swapp & Associates, we help clients prepare for defense medical exams, respond to insurance company tactics, and pursue fair compensation while protecting their legal interests.
A defense medical exam (DME), frequently referred to as an Independent Medical Exam (IME), is a medical evaluation requested by the defendant or the defendant’s insurance company after an injury claim has been filed. Despite the common term “independent,” the physician performing the examination is generally selected and paid by the defense, making the evaluation part of the litigation process rather than ongoing medical treatment.
Unlike your treating physician, whose primary responsibility is diagnosing and treating your injuries, the physician conducting a defense medical exam serves a different purpose. The doctor evaluates your medical condition, reviews your records, and prepares a report that may become evidence during settlement discussions or at trial.
Insurance companies and defense attorneys request defense medical exams for several reasons, all centered on evaluating and challenging the injury claim.
The defense wants its own physician to assess whether the injuries are as serious as claimed. The examiner may compare current symptoms with medical records, diagnostic imaging, and prior treatment history.
One of the most significant issues in a personal injury case is causation: the legal principle requiring the injured person to prove that the defendant’s negligence caused the injuries.
A defense physician may argue that:
If accepted, these opinions may reduce or eliminate compensation.
Many personal injury claims include compensation for future medical care, rehabilitation, surgeries, medications, or ongoing therapy.
A defense physician may conclude that:
Such opinions may significantly reduce the value of future damages.
The physician’s written report frequently becomes one of the defense’s strongest pieces of evidence. Insurance adjusters often rely on these reports when deciding whether to offer a settlement, dispute damages, or continue litigation.
If the case proceeds to trial, the examining physician may testify as an expert witness regarding the examination findings.
Defense medical exams affect nearly every stage of a personal injury claim.
Perhaps the greatest impact occurs when the defense physician disagrees with your treating doctors.
Examples include opinions that:
This creates conflicting medical opinions that must be evaluated by insurance companies, judges, or juries.
Insurance companies frequently use defense medical exams to justify lower settlement offers. If the report states that injuries are minor, recovery is complete, treatment was excessive, or permanent impairment does not exist, the insurer may argue that compensation should be reduced accordingly. Conversely, a well-documented claim supported by consistent medical records often makes these arguments less persuasive.
Credibility matters throughout every injury case. The examining physician may observe how you walk, whether you follow instructions, consistency between complaints and physical movement, and your responses during testing.
Defense attorneys sometimes compare these observations with surveillance footage, social media posts, prior medical records, or deposition testimony to argue inconsistencies.
This does not mean injured people should exaggerate or minimize symptoms. Instead, they should answer questions honestly and describe their actual limitations.
Defense medical exam reports often become central evidence during litigation. Attorneys may question the physician regarding examination methods, medical conclusions, review of diagnostic testing, assumptions made during the evaluation, and compensation received for performing litigation examinations. Cross-examination helps juries determine how much weight should be given to the physician’s opinions compared to those of treating doctors.
Preparation and honesty are essential before, during, and after a defense medical exam.
Never exaggerate symptoms. Likewise, do not minimize pain simply to appear strong. Accurate information is usually more persuasive than dramatic descriptions.
Unlike visits with your own physician, the defense examiner is not providing medical treatment. The examination is intended to gather information for litigation. Understanding that distinction helps injured individuals answer questions carefully while avoiding unnecessary conversation unrelated to the examination.
Immediately after leaving, write down how long the examination lasted, what tests were performed, questions that were asked, comments made by the physician, and anyone present during the examination. These notes may become valuable if the physician’s report later differs from what actually occurred.
Never stop medical treatment because a defense medical exam has been scheduled. Consistent medical care demonstrates that recovery remains important and creates an ongoing record documenting your injuries. Missed appointments or treatment gaps may allow insurers to argue that injuries have improved or were never serious.
Defense medical exams rarely determine the outcome of a case by themselves. Instead, they become one piece of evidence that must be analyzed alongside other pieces of personal injury evidence.
At Craig Swapp & Associates, we represent injured clients throughout Utah, Idaho, Washington, Montana, Oregon, Wyoming, Colorado, and Arizona by preparing them for defense medical exams, challenging unfair medical opinions, and pursuing the compensation they deserve. Our team of personal injury attorneys believes getting the right legal guidance should be simple — “one call, that’s all.” Call us at 866-308-3822 or contact us using our online form to schedule your free initial consultation.
Written By: Ryan Swapp Legal Review By: Craig Swapp